Site icon Todd K Marsha

Critics Say Synod Report Undermines Church Teaching, Misrepresents Courage| National Catholic Register

The Vatican is seen on May 6.

<p><&excl;-- BEGIN THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p> <br &sol;>&NewLine;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<div>&NewLine;<p>A study group’s final report from the 2024 Synod on Synodality released Tuesday has been roundly criticized for attempting to change the Church’s teaching on homosexuality and for misrepresenting an apostolate&comma; in good standing with the Church&comma; that ministers to same-sex-attracted faithful&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The final <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;vaticannews&period;va&sol;en&sol;pope&sol;news&sol;2024-03&sol;pope-francis-indicates-to-cardinal-grech-ten-themes-for-synod&period;html">report<&sol;a> of Study Group 9 — entitled &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Theological Criteria and Synod Methodologies for Shared Discernment of Emerging Doctrinal&comma; Pastoral&comma; and Ethical Issues” — contains various topics that Pope Francis <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;vaticannews&period;va&sol;en&sol;pope&sol;news&sol;2024-03&sol;pope-francis-indicates-to-cardinal-grech-ten-themes-for-synod&period;html">wished to set aside<&sol;a> from the 2023-2024 Synod on Synodality assemblies because he said there was not enough time to study the topics before the 2024 assembly&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Among the topics&comma; which included ecumenism and the role of bishops&comma; were Study Group 9’s &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;controversial” doctrinal&comma; pastoral and ethical issues&comma; including those surrounding same-sex relations&period; The report explains that the word &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;controversial” was replaced in the report with &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;emerging issues” in the final report in order to &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;experience an authentic &OpenCurlyQuote;paradigm shift&period;’” The report maintains that a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;paradigm shift” was a process initiated by the Second Vatican Council to challenge models of ecclesial life prevalent over the past centuries&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Setting the stage for what Catholic LGBTQ-rights activists <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;newwaysministry&period;org&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;06&sol;synod-study-group-report-on-lgbtq-issues-is-released-new-ways-ministry-responds&sol;">have described as a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;surprisingly progressive” view of same-sex relations<&sol;a>&comma; the report goes on to say that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;pastorality” is its interpretative horizon&period; It underscores a concept of &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;relational conversion” that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;demands learning through experience&comma;” and offers guidelines for pastoral discernment on two specific emerging issues&colon; the experience of homosexual Catholics and the commitment to active non-violence&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The report speaks of &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;discernment through conversation in the Spirit” having three &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;modes” which it defines as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;listening to ourselves&comma;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;paying attention to reality&comma;” and &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;summoning various forms of expertise&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The authors of the report included Cardinal Carlos Castillo Mattasoglio of Lima&comma; Peru&comma; <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;cardinal-carlos-gustavo-castillo-mattasoglio&sol;">known for some theologically heterodox<&sol;a> positions&comma; including on homosexuality&semi; Archbishop Filippo Iannone&comma; the prefect of the Dicastery for Bishops&semi; Italian moral theologian Father Maurizio Chiodi&comma; who has argued that <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;blog&sol;new-jpii-institute-professors-question-church-orthodoxy-on-homosexuality-contraception&quest;utm&lowbar;source&equals;perplexity">contraception<&sol;a> can be morally permissible for married couples in some circumstances based on <i>Amoris Laetitia<&sol;i>&comma; and that homosexual relationships &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;under certain conditions” could be &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the most fruitful way” for those with same-sex attractions to enjoy good relations&semi; and Jesuit Father Carlo Casalone&comma; a moral theologian who in 2022 was criticized for <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;news&sol;pontifical-academy-for-life-members-support-for-assisted-suicide-draws-criticism">urging support for assisted suicide<&sol;a> as a tactic to prevent the legalization of voluntary euthanasia in Italy&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The report then moves on to reporting on testimonies that form part of the overall Study Group 9 submission&comma; from two Catholic men who are monogamously &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;married” to other men&period; With the inclusion of these testimonies&comma; the report says the aim was to demonstrate how local Churches can practice synodal discernment through identifying the developmental stages within these stories&comma; and to ask guiding questions&period; The goal&comma; they said&comma; is to initiate processes rather than provide universal solutions&comma; respecting that local Churches themselves will adapt and implement this approach within their own contexts&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<h3>Two Testimonies<&sol;h3>&NewLine;<p>The author of the first testimony&comma; a man from Portugal&comma; contended that the Lord gave him all that was needed to build a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;life of shared faith and service with my husband&period;” He recalled how the family of his &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;husband” believed they were &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;living a life of sin” but their &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;hearts began to open” when they noticed &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;subtle signs of support and love” from their parish&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Reflecting on the testimony&comma; the report asserts that homosexual relationships are not sinful&comma; saying the testimony &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;bears witness to the discovery that sin&comma; at its root&comma; does not consist in the &lpar;same sex&rpar; couple relationship&comma; but in a lack of faith in a God who desires our fulfilment&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The second testimony&comma; written by an American also &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;married” to a man&comma; began by saying his sexuality &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;isn’t a perversion&comma; disorder&comma; or cross&semi; it’s a gift from God&period; I have a happy&comma; healthy marriage and am flourishing as an openly gay Catholic&period;” He said he joined the Courage apostolate at the University of Notre Dame&comma; making a point that it works with people who &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;suffer” from same-sex attraction&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The author of the testimony maintained that the apostolate &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;did little to help my spiritual and psychosexual development&comma;” and added that the people he met were &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;lonely&comma; hopeless&comma; and often depressed&period;” The witness said Courage had been recommended to him by a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;conversion therapist” — in another passage&comma; the report’s authors conflated the witness’s words with the erroneous claim that Courage International was pushing reparative therapy which &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;had the effect of separating faith and sexuality&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Courage International is a respected and canonically approved Catholic apostolate founded in 1980 to provide spiritual support to men and women experiencing same-sex attractions who wish to live chastely according to Church teaching&period; Moreover&comma; the apostolate has long been adamant that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;<a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;couragerc&period;org&sol;statement-regarding-remarks-in-the-seanad-ireland&sol;">it does not provide&comma; refer for&comma; or require any form of therapy for its members<&sol;a>&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The witness went on to say it was when he studied for a doctorate at Jesuit Fordham University that he said he felt affirmed in his sexual identity&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;The Catholicism that keeps me Catholic welcomes me as I am&comma;” he wrote&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The report did not disclose the identity of the witness&comma; although some observers&comma; including the homosexual advocacy group <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;newwaysministry&period;org&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;06&sol;synod-study-group-report-on-lgbtq-issues-is-released-new-ways-ministry-responds&sol;">New Ways Ministry<&sol;a>&comma; publicly speculated based on biographical details in the testimony that the author was a prominent advocate for normalizing same-sex relationships in the Church&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The synod report and testimonies have been enthusiastically welcomed by LGBTQ rights groups pushing for a normalization of same-sex relationships in the Church&period; Francis DeBernardo of New Ways Ministry said the document was a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;<a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;newwaysministry&period;org&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;06&sol;synod-study-group-report-on-lgbtq-issues-is-released-new-ways-ministry-responds&sol;">breath of refreshing air<&sol;a>” that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;surprised many because of how progressive it was&period;” Father James Martin <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;newwaysministry&period;org&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;07&sol;catholic-lgbtq-advocates-welcome-study-group-9-report-and-what-did-the-report-say-about-reparative-therapy&sol;">called<&sol;a> it a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;big deal&comma;” adding it was the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;first time” a Vatican publication had included such testimonies&period; Marianne Duddy-Burke&comma; executive director of DignityUSA&comma; an LGBTQ Church lobby group&comma; <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;newwaysministry&period;org&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;07&sol;catholic-lgbtq-advocates-welcome-study-group-9-report-and-what-did-the-report-say-about-reparative-therapy&sol;">said<&sol;a> the most significant aspect to her was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the recognition that top-down trying to dictate behavior and morality on the basis of dogma isn’t working&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<h3>Critics Respond<&sol;h3>&NewLine;<p>Those faithful to the Church’s moral teaching have strongly objected to the report&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Gerhard Müller criticized the report’s authors&comma; saying in a statement they &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;do not openly deny revealed truths&comma; but set them aside and&comma; alongside them&comma; build their own house of a comfortable and world-conforming Christianity&period;” The former Vatican doctrinal chief condemned how &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the pro-LGBT lobby” within the Church had &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;openly welcomed” such &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;heretical relativization of natural and sacramental marriage&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Father Gerald Murray&comma; a canonist and priest of the Archdiocese of New York&comma; said he found the report &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;horrific” and a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;subversive attempt to overthrow Catholic morality on the question of homosexuality&period;” He <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;youtube&period;com&sol;watch&quest;v&equals;wIRwGhv-1gY">told<&sol;a> EWTN’s Raymond Arroyo May 7 that he believes the synod office has become a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;public relations arm” of a pressure group seeking to subvert Catholic teaching &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;on the immoral nature of homosexual activity&period;” He also called it &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;an outrage” to use the testimony of a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;lobbyist for the gay rights movement in the Catholic Church&comma;” saying it was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;manipulative of the synod office” to include it&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The report also unsurprisingly received opprobrium from Courage International&period; In a May 8 <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;couragerc&period;org&sol;wp-content&sol;uploads&sol;2026&sol;05&sol;Courage-Internationals-Response-to-the-Synodal-Report&period;pdf">statement<&sol;a>&comma; it denounced the report&comma; saying it committed &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;both calumny and detraction against the organization and its members&period;” The group repudiated the report’s claim that it engages in &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;reparative therapy” and argued that Synod officials could have verified this by simply contacting Courage leadership rather than relying on a single person’s account&period; It also defended its meetings as confidential&comma; rather than &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;secretive” as the witness had claimed&comma; emphasizing that this privacy enables members to speak openly about their struggles with loneliness and depression without fear of being publicly characterized&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The organization said it was a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;great sadness” that such mischaracterization of Courage appeared in an official Vatican document rather than what would usually come from secular critics&comma; and offered to meet with Synod officials to provide accurate information about its 45-year apostolate&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>In comments to the Register&comma; the executive director of Courage&comma; Father Brian Gannon&comma; also regretted that Courage was not represented in the study group&comma; and that it chose two witnesses who each object to the Church’s moral teaching as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the sole sources&period;” This made it contradictory to the synod’s intentions&comma; he told the Register&period; He also stressed that Courage does not engage in reparative therapy&comma; adding that the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;key to Courage’s ministry” is &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;personal accompaniment&comma; and grace through the sacraments&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Father Kyle Schnippel&comma; a Courage chaplain and chair of the apostolate’s board of directors&comma; said he found the report &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;disappointing” and &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;disheartening” for Courage’s members&comma; especially because <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;cna&sol;historic-occasion-pope-leo-xiv-meets-with-same-sex-attraction-ministry-courage-international">Pope Leo XIV had just met with its leaders<&sol;a>&period; He stressed that Courage is about conversion — conversion to Jesus — and that when one lives &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;in accord with what the Church teaches&comma; what Jesus teaches&comma; we find peace&period;” He told the Register that his experience working with Courage as a priest for the past 12 years has made him a better priest&comma; and he sees the good fruits of its ministry &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;every day&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Both Father Gannon and Father Schnippel said they would like to see the hierarchy speak up about the problems with the report&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Mary Rice Hasson&comma; a board member of Courage&comma; said the study group report was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;unethical” and &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;should be retracted&period;” She said she was unaware of a Vatican study group ever &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;publicly&comma; purposefully&comma; and arbitrarily” disparaging a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;public&comma; clerical association” of the faithful in good standing with the Church&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;For a Vatican report to carelessly cast aspersions on Courage membership&comma; while misrepresenting Courage’s mission&comma; is a serious failure in its obligation towards charity and the truth&comma;” Hasson told the Register&period; The study group’s actions&comma; she added&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;betray commitment to an ideological agenda over commitment to the truth&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Müller said the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;LGBT ideology” advocates &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;nothing other than a materialistic view of humanity without God&comma; the Creator&comma; Redeemer&comma; and Perfecter of humankind&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>He added&colon; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Anyone who&comma; as a teacher of the faith and shepherd of the faithful appointed by Christ&comma; is truly interested in the inner peace of soul and the eternal salvation of the faithful entrusted to him&comma; does not make people in difficult situations the playthings of a godless ideology or the instruments of his own desire for prominence in the woke milieu&comma; but rather points them personally to Jesus Christ&comma; the Son of God&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The final report of Study Group 9&comma; and all documents from the 2024 synod&comma; will be subject to a process of evaluation and implementation&comma; from the diocesan level to national episcopal conferences&comma; beginning this summer and culminating in the final Ecclesial Assembly at the Vatican in October 2028&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;p><&sol;div>&NewLine;<p><br &sol;>&NewLine;<br &sol;><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;news&sol;pentin-synod-study-group-9-oeuxm9iw">Source link <&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><&excl;-- END THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version