Site icon Todd K Marsha

Nothing on Earth, Not Even Mortal Sin, Can Dissolve an Indissoluble Marriage| National Catholic Register

Emanuel Leutze’s 1846 painting “The Courtship of Anne Boleyn” depicts King Henry VIII and Anne Boleyn (l) and Catherine of Aragon (r).

<p><&excl;-- BEGIN THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p> <br &sol;>&NewLine;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<div>&NewLine;<p>&OpenCurlyQuote;Unity&comma; indissolubility&comma; and openness to fertility are essential to marriage&period;’ &lpar;CCC 1664&rpar;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;p><&sol;div>&NewLine;<div>&NewLine;<p>At Catholic tribunals across the dioceses of America&comma; the subject of marital infidelity is a frequent discussion&period; Since <i>the intention of sexual fidelity at the time of the marriage<&sol;i> is required for marriage validity&comma; a future act of infidelity is sometimes viewed as grounds for annulment&period; In the eyes of some tribunalists&comma; an act of infidelity serves as proof that fidelity was never intended in the first place&period; Is this a logical and theologically sound stance&quest; The answer is <i>no<&sol;i>&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Before the comments box fills up with notions that I am somehow defending sexual infidelity&comma; let me be clear&period; Sexual infidelity is serious — that is&comma; mortal sin — matter&period; It makes one an enemy of God and thus of the good angels&period; It destroys relationships with human persons&period; It very often causes severe scandal and irreparable harm to spouses&comma; entire families&comma; and on a broader scale&comma; entire societies&period; Considering Mary’s message at Fatima&comma; we have every reason to believe that many souls go to Hell for eternity because of unconfessed sexual infidelity&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>All this said&comma; however&comma; infidelity is not grounds for annulment&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>If the bride or groom at the ceremony intends to be unfaithful&comma; and simply mouths the words promising faithfulness&comma; the marriage is not valid&period; Along with <i>openness to children<&sol;i> and <i>affirmation of indissolubility<&sol;i>&comma; the intention of sexual fidelity is required&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>On the other hand&comma; if a Catholic bride and groom intend lifelong fidelity&comma; future infidelities do not and cannot cancel the fact that they formed a valid marriage&period; Everything necessary regarding the intention of sexual fidelity was present at their wedding&semi; this is an <i>unchangeable<&sol;i> reality&period; There might be impediments illustrating that theirs was never a marriage&comma; but an act &lpar;or many acts&rpar; of infidelity can change nothing about the validity of the marriage&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>History offers us confirmation of this sacramental reality&period; It was widely known throughout Christendom that King Henry VIII cheated on Catherine of Aragon with numerous women&period; Yet&comma; Rome affirmed the validity of Henry’s marriage to Catherine — as did St&period; Thomas More all the way to the scaffold&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Many readers might be asking questions like&colon; But what about a woman who carries on an affair only 18 months after her wedding&quest; Wouldn’t that affair provide evidence that she never intended fidelity in the first place&quest; For that matter&comma; what about a scoundrel who cheats on his wife during his own honeymoon at Niagara Falls&quest; Certainly&comma; that would be an invalid marriage&comma; right&quest; After all&comma; it would be impossible to believe that a man — who truly intended fidelity just days prior — cheated on his wife&comma; right&quest;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Wrong&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>To illustrate why this is wrong&comma; we can remain within the realm of sacramental theology&period; Imagine a man goes to Confession with deep sorrow for his sins along with a firm purpose of amendment&period; The priest hears his sins&comma; grants the man absolution&comma; and the man says or does his penance&period; But imagine that the man commits one of those same sins just three days later&period; Is that evidence that his sorrow was merely an act&quest; Does that prove that his purpose of amendment was fraudulent&quest; We might follow these questions with a more introspective one&colon; Who among us has never been in that man’s shoes&quest;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>When pondering these questions&comma; we should also keep in mind that the Church recommends frequent confession&period; How frequent&quest; At Fatima&comma; Our Lady asked us to go to Confession on five consecutive months&period; But if <i>firm purpose of amendment<&sol;i> meant never sinning again&comma; what need would there be of going to Confession ever again&comma; much less every month&quest; Clearly&comma; a man could have a sincere and firm intention of amendment&comma; yet fall back into the same sins&period; But this does not make his Confession invalid&period; Nor should we even entertain thoughts that his absolution might be invalid&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Let’s illustrate this a bit further&period; Dioceses have marriage tribunals that investigate and help determine the validity of marriages&period; But for a moment&comma; imagine that there existed tribunals not just to determine the validity of the vocational sacraments&comma; but for all seven sacraments&period; Imagine that a confessional tribunal convened to determine a penitent’s validity based on his level of sorrow and his firmness of amendment&period; The opening statement of the prosecutor would likely be&colon; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It would be impossible to think that a man — who supposedly intended a <i>firm purpose of amendment<&sol;i> just days prior — committed a sin no more than 72 hours later&excl;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The penitent intended amendment at the moment&comma; and that is what matters&period; Subsequent actions cannot change that reality&period; The same is true for marriage&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Society has normalized the tragedies of infidelity&comma; contraception and no-fault divorce&period; And that mentality — whether we realize it or not&comma; whether we want it to or not — has split over into our view of annulments&period; That mentality puts the sacraments in dangerous harm&period; Because to argue that infidelity makes a marriage retrospectively invalid is to misunderstand not only Matrimony&comma; but to misapprehend the very nature of the sacraments&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>So let’s be clear&period; Nothing can &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;make” a consummated Catholic marriage <i>invalid<&sol;i>&period; Not a local marriage tribunal&comma; not your bishop&comma; not the pope &lpar;neither the Petrine nor Pauline privilege applies to consummated Catholic marriages&rpar;&period; They could no more un-make a marriage than they could un-baptize a baby&comma; un-absolve absolution&comma; un-confirm a teenager&comma; un-consecrate the Eucharist&comma; un-anoint the sick or un-ordain a priest&period; Sacraments are unshakable physical&comma; metaphysical and spiritual realities&period; To doubt this is the stuff of heresy&comma; apostasy&comma; schism and sadness&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>One last point&period; Over the years&comma; I have made it a habit that whenever I write about mortal sin&comma; I always reference Confession&period; The virtues of truth&comma; justice and charity demand as much&period; This topic of infidelity is no different&period; In the sacrament of Penance&comma; God forgives sexual infidelity&period; Never doubt that&period; A man may walk into Confession with thousands of mortal sins on his soul that he has accumulated for many decades&period; But he walks out in the state of sanctifying grace — an indwelling of the Trinity and a friendship with God&period; The sacraments — <i>all<&sol;i> the sacraments — are powerful indeed&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>As is the mercy of God&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;p><&sol;div>&NewLine;<p><br &sol;>&NewLine;<br &sol;><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;blog&sol;john-clark-infidelity-and-indissolubility">Source link <&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><&excl;-- END THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version