Site icon Todd K Marsha

The Return of the Ring and Tolkien’s ‘Fundamentally Catholic’ Work| National Catholic Register

‘Map of Middle-earth’

<p><&excl;-- BEGIN THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p> <br &sol;>&NewLine;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<div>&NewLine;<p>It’s more than 20 years since Peter Jackson’s blockbusting three-part adaptation of Tolkien’s epic&comma; <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i>&comma; was first released&period; Now it has returned for a three-day-run at movie theaters&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>J&period; R&period; R&period; Tolkien was a lifelong and devout practicing Catholic who asserted that <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;a fundamentally religious and Catholic work&period;” How faithful was Peter Jackson’s adaptation to the religious and Catholic aspects of the work&quest;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Holly Ordway&comma; author of <i>Tolkien’s Faith&colon; A Spiritual Biography<&sol;i>&comma; published last year by Word on Fire&comma; is effusive in affirming Jackson’s fidelity to the spirit of Tolkien’s original story&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;I think that his <i>Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> trilogy&comma; as seen in the Extended Editions &lpar;not the theatrical cuts&rpar; is indeed faithful to the overall ethos of Tolkien’s work&comma;” she says&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It captures much of what is good&comma; true&comma; and beautiful in Tolkien’s vision&comma; most especially in treating goodness&comma; humility&comma; and self-sacrifice as genuinely positive and attractive qualities&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Louis Markos&comma; author of two Tolkien-related books&comma; <i>On the Shoulders of Hobbits&colon; The Road to Virtue with Tolkien and Lewis<&sol;i> and <i>Tolkien for Beginners<&sol;i>&comma; shares Ordway’s enthusiasm&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;I think it was fully faithful to the spirit of the books and&comma; with the exception of Faramir&comma; to most of the characters&comma;” he states&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>An additional positive consequence of the phenomenal success of Jackson’s films&comma; according to Markos&comma; was its introduction of Tolkien’s book to a new generation of readers&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It has made Tolkien’s epic accessible and engaging for viewers of all ages and drawn people to the novel&comma;” he says&period; Another positive outcome&comma; in Markos’ judgment&comma; is the way that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;it has made courage and virtue attractive again to a jaded age&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Joshua Hren&comma; editor of Wiseblood Books and author of <i>Middle-Earth and the Return of the Common Good&colon; J&period;R&period;R&period; Tolkien and Political Philosophy<&sol;i>&comma; is less effusive but shares Markos’ view that the films had led people to the book&period; Refraining from commenting on the merits or otherwise of the films&comma; Hren is pleased that many people had read <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> who might not have done so had they not first seen the films&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;I am grateful for the films in large part because they had the blessed &OpenCurlyQuote;side effect’ of sending folks back to Tolkien’s books&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>A different and dissident perspective is offered by Romanian Tolkien scholar&comma; Robert Lazu Kmita&period; The author of the novel <i>The Island Without Seasons<&sol;i> and coordinator of an encyclopedia about Tolkien’s world &lpar;in Romanian&rpar;&comma; Kmita acknowledges the success of the film cinematographically but questions its fidelity to Tolkien’s Catholic ethos&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;In terms of the sets&comma; costumes&comma; the representation of the different races &lpar;except for the elves&rpar;&comma; the filming locations&comma; and other such external aspects&comma; the films are successful&comma;” he concedes&comma; but &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;in terms of capturing the spirit of Tolkien’s stories&comma; they have failed&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Asked to elaborate&comma; Kmita&comma; states that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;there are many things that can be said here”&colon; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Tolkien’s world&comma; very concretely speaking&comma; is the medieval Catholic world&colon; hierarchical&comma; royal&comma; sacral&comma; austere&comma; with a strong emphasis on the traditional Christian virtues&period; Generally&comma; all these aspects are greatly diminished and&sol;or misrepresented through the transformation of the wonderful stories of Middle-Earth into a sort of &OpenCurlyQuote;action movie&period;’”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Another problem that Kmita highlights is the way in which romantic or erotic love is portrayed in the films compared with the way in which they are treated by Tolkien&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Failing to understand the absence of carnal &OpenCurlyQuote;passionate love’ in Tolkien’s stories&comma;” Kmita says&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the filmmakers of <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> included passionate kisses and incandescent embraces&comma; especially in the portrayal of the love of Aragorn and Arwen&period;” Such deviations from the spirit of Tolkien’s work helped to explain why Tolkien’s son&comma; Christopher&comma; the chief custodian of his father’s literary legacy until his own recent death&comma; had been such a vocal critic of the films&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;The reservations expressed by Christopher Tolkien regarding the adaptations of <i>The Hobbit<&sol;i> and <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> can hardly be dismissed&comma;” says Kmita&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Returning to the topic of what he calls &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Tolkien’s True Love&comma;” the title of an article he wrote recently for <i>The European Conservative<&sol;i>&comma; Kmita is insistent that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the values of Tolkien’s world are not those of contemporary moral relativism&comma; but those of the traditional Christian conception of courtship and romantic loyalty&comma; in which the intimate and delicate aspects of love are treated with discretion and respect that protects their nobility&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Having given the case for the prosecution of Peter Jackson for desecrating <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i>&comma; let’s return to the case for the defense&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Holly Ordway defends the film with an admirable diffidence and deference to Tolkien’s original work&period; She respects the fact that Peter Jackson did not seek to undermine the ethos of Tolkien’s epic with any overt agenda-driven agenda of his own&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;There is no taint of irony&comma; parody&comma; or subversion here&comma;” Ordway notes&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It’s authentically wholesome&comma; in the proper use of that word as nourishing and satisfying&period;” She is also pleased that &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Jackson exercises commendable restraint in not adding elements from his own vision to Tolkien’s world&comma;” a view which would no doubt be disputed by Kmita and others of a similarly purist persuasion&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Ordway refers to the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;many contributing elements to the films that help them to be faithful to the tone and style of the books&comma; as well as to their moral core&period;” She singles out Howard Shore’s quasi-Wagnerian musical score&comma; describing it as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;superb” and having &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the right &OpenCurlyQuote;feel’ for the story&comma; and the visuals&comma; which are beautifully faithful&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Weighing against these positive features of Jackson’s films are their defects&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;To be sure&comma; Jackson doesn’t fully understand all of Tolkien’s characters&comma;” Ordway adds&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;For instance&comma; the film Denethor is disagreeable&comma; almost a caricature&comma; but in the book&comma; he is a genuinely noble character who has gone wrong through despair&colon; his demise is tragic precisely because of his potential greatness&period; However&comma; on the whole&comma; I feel that Jackson gets things right&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Ordway contrasts the great job that she considers Jackson did with <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> with his downright dereliction of duty in his subsequent adaptation of <i>The Hobbit<&sol;i>&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Jackson’s <i>Hobbit<&sol;i> adaptations show no understanding or appreciation for the ethos and tone of the book&comma; nor of its narrative structure and pacing&comma;” Orway complains&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;A much shorter book is bloated out into three films&comma; and it’s made to be an action-adventure rather than the gentle and thoughtful story that Tolkien wrote&period;” She adds that characters like Radagast &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;are played for cheap laughs&comma; in a way that’s not consonant with Tolkien’s own sense of humor” and&comma; unlike in <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i> films&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Jackson doesn’t restrain himself from altering the content&comma; adding in new characters and material that jars with the story as Tolkien wrote it&period;” Her final judgment on <i>The Hobbit<&sol;i> adaptations&comma; which are surely the result of Peter Jackson’s suffering from the dragon sickness when he was making it&comma; is one in which she is no doubt in agreement with purists&comma; such as Kmita&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It’s a film with <i>Hobbit <&sol;i>decor&comma;” she states&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;not a film of <i>The Hobbit<&sol;i>&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>As for the final judgment of these Tolkien experts on Jackson’s adaptation of <i>The Lord of the Rings<&sol;i>&comma; Joshua Hren appears to be non-committal and Robert Lazu Kmita gives a resolute thumbs-down&period; By contrast&comma; Holly Ordway gives &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;an enthusiastic thumbs-up” and Louis Markos gives &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;a definite thumbs-up&comma; for it brings Middle-earth to shimmering life in all its layers&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Having heard the views of the experts&comma; we can now revisit the films and judge for ourselves&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;p><&sol;div>&NewLine;<p><br &sol;>&NewLine;<br &sol;><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;features&sol;return-of-the-ring-tolkiens-fundamentally-catholic-work">Source link <&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><&excl;-- END THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version