Site icon Todd K Marsha

Too Short, Too Structured? Cardinals Reflect on Synodal Consistory| National Catholic Register

The cardinals gather for Mass with Pope Leo at St. Peter’s Basilica on June 26, 2026, during their consistory.

<p><&excl;-- BEGIN THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p> <br &sol;>&NewLine;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<div>&NewLine;<p>VATICAN CITY — Cardinals who attended Pope Leo XIV’s second extraordinary consistory said they valued parts of the meeting&comma; but found it too brief&comma; insufficiently focused on urgent internal Church issues&comma; and too tightly structured to allow enough free discussion&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Held at the Vatican June 26-27&comma; the gathering brought together 178 members of the College of Cardinals from around the world&period; It was the second such meeting convened by Pope Leo after a 12-year hiatus under Pope Francis&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Structured along &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;synodal” lines&comma; the consistory divided participants into small language groups to discuss pre-set themes&comma; including Pope Leo’s first encyclical&comma; <i>Magnifica Humanitas<&sol;i>&comma; the promotion of the common good&comma; and implementation of the 2023-2024 Synod on Synodality&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Broader global concerns such as war&comma; poverty&comma; social fragmentation&comma; and a growing sense of loneliness and loss of meaning <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ewtnnews&period;com&sol;vatican&sol;cardinals-confront-a-wounded-world-at-opening-of-synodal-consistory">featured prominently&comma;<&sol;a> while internal Church questions were largely omitted and confined to a brief final plenary session&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Several cardinals told the Register of their general satisfaction with the meeting&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It was very nice that we had the opportunity to share our stories&comma;” said <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;cardinal-tarcisio-isao-kikuchi-s-v-d&sol;">Cardinal Tarcisio Kikuchi of Tokyo<&sol;a>&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It was just like a synod&comma; a continuation of the synod&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;antoine-kambanda&sol;">Cardinal Antoine Kimbanda<&sol;a> of Kigali&comma; Rwanda&comma; said the consistory &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;was wonderful&comma;” as it &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;had the spirit of synodality&comma; listening to one another&comma; walking together like the Synod on Synodality&period;” He said that as far as he was aware&comma; his African brother cardinals were &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;all happy” with the meeting&comma; adding that the consistory enabled them to get to know one another&comma; especially the retired cardinals&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;who have longer experience&period;” This enabled them to &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;listen to one another&comma; and learn from one another&comma; and walk together&comma;” he said&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;cardinal-jaime-spengler-o-f-m&sol;">Cardinal Jaime Spengler<&sol;a> of Porto Alegre&comma; Brazil&comma; likewise described the consistory as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;truly a space and a time&comma; I think&comma; of communion&comma; of fraternity&comma; and at the same time of great transparency&period;” &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;It was truly a pleasure&comma;” he said&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;to be able to share a bit about the situation&comma; not only of the Church in the world but also to sense the historical moment we’re living through because of wars&comma; polarization&comma; and also inequality&comma; which is a scandal&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>According to Cardinal Spengler&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;not only could everyone speak up but had to speak up&comma;” and &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;no one could say&comma; &OpenCurlyQuote;This or that situation has nothing to do with me&period;’” He said he was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;struck deeply” by <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ewtnnews&period;com&sol;vatican&sol;pope-leo-xiv-closes-consistory-with-appeal-to-help-world-find-god-s-paths-to-peace">Pope Leo’s closing address<&sol;a>&comma; calling it a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;fantastic summary” of what &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;really happened over these two days&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;raymond-leo-burke&sol;">Cardinal Raymond Burke<&sol;a>&comma; prefect emeritus of the Apostolic Signatura&comma; said the cardinals are &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;certainly grateful” to the Pope for convening such meetings again&comma; and he noted that they are speaking more with one another&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;We’re getting to know each other more&comma; and that’s very great fruit&comma;” he said&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;collegeofcardinalsreport&period;com&sol;cardinals&sol;gerhard-ludwig-muller&sol;">Cardinal Gerhard Müller<&sol;a>&comma; prefect emeritus of the Dicastery for the Doctrine of the Faith&comma; welcomed the fact that the consistory &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;has returned the College of Cardinals to its proper role&colon; to advise the Pope and to be his first helper&period;” He said Pope Leo is well informed and educated&comma; yet &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;not an autocrat or anything above the world&comma; but a human being like anyone else&period;” This means he must &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;always be in contact and dialogue with all his brothers in the same mission&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<h3><b>Concerns Over Synodal Structure<&sol;b><&sol;h3>&NewLine;<p>However&comma; concerns were raised about the brevity of the consistory and its &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;synodal” structure&comma; which some participants thought had stifled discussion about pressing issues&comma; especially within the Church&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Burke said that unlike consistories over a decade ago&comma; when cardinals could freely express their concerns to the Pope in plenary sessions&comma; the cardinals were told that the consistory must now be &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;conformed to synodality&period;” It was &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;no longer an open debate&comma;” Cardinal Burke said&comma; but rather was centered around small tables&comma; to follow &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;this system of questions proposed&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;We don’t get to the heart of matters in depth&comma;” he told the Register June 29&comma; adding that the reports &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;are only the reports of what every cardinal agreed upon&period;” Thus&comma; if a cardinal brings up a topic which others do not agree with&comma; but which &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;could be very true and important for the Pope to hear&comma; that doesn’t get reported to him&comma;” he said&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Müller agreed with these criticisms of the structure&comma; saying that the small tables in a synodal format are &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;more a form of modern education of young people” or suitable for the Jesuits or Augustinians&comma; but not for consistories&period; In the past&comma; he said&comma; all cardinals were able to give statements in plenary &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;that everyone can hear and share&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;The main thing must be the plenary&comma;” he said&comma; adding that he preferred &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;prepared&comma; reflected&comma; written statements that are formulated weeks before&comma; not words that come only from the situation&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;We can serve and help the Pope with our own reflections&comma; not with what is manipulated and controlled beforehand&comma;” Cardinal Müller said&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;I do not need a &OpenCurlyQuote;leader’ to prepare what I have to say&period; We have too much in today’s society of this thinking&comma; where others want to lead us and prepare our words&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>For the cardinal&comma; a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;better solution” must be found&comma; one in which synodality is not &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;exaggerated as a solution for everything&period;” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Unlike Pope Leo’s first extraordinary consistory in January&comma; the June meeting did include an hour-long &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;free discussion” session at the end&comma; but each cardinal was allotted only three minutes instead of the five or six that used to be the norm&period; Cardinal Müller noted that courtesies and greetings already consumed part of that time&comma; leaving very little space for substantive remarks&comma; and Cardinal Burke said he did not have enough time to deliver his prepared intervention &lpar;talk&rpar;&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<h3><b>Consistory Too Short<&sol;b><&sol;h3>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Kikuchi told the Register that dividing the cardinals into small-language groups &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;actually limited” their discussions because&comma; as a cardinal from Asia&comma; he could not hear firsthand about the situation of the Church in Latin America&period; He also judged the overall time too short&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;There was a suggestion that&comma; next year&comma; we should have at least four days&comma;” he said&period; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;Maybe next time&comma; we’re going to have more time&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Several cardinals lamented that pressing internal Church matters were hardly raised&period; The Register has learned that just one cardinal brought up the question of the Society of St&period; Pius X and its imminent&comma; likely schismatic act of consecrating bishops without a papal mandate — and only because he found a propitious moment to mention it&period; The topic was not placed on the agenda&comma; and apart from that single intervention&comma; the SSPX issue was not raised at all&period; Nor&comma; during the rest of the consistory&comma; were other critical matters&comma; such as the highly controversial German Synodal Path or questions about what some cardinals regard as the influence of a so-called gay lobby in the Church&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Burke called the SSPX question &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;the proverbial elephant in the room” and said he believed the cardinals &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;should be giving the Holy Father our best counsel on how to go forward&period;” But he and others argued that the synodal format&comma; together with the limited time&comma; precluded such sustained counsel&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Kikuchi noted that if the cardinals had begun to discuss the SSPX or other delicate internal issues without proper preparation&comma; the debate might easily have devolved into a clash over whether some cardinals favored or opposed them&period; Yet the SSPX question&comma; he stressed&comma; is &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;not based on feelings” but on theological and canonical considerations that require careful study&period; The cardinals&comma; he said&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;do not want to feel like a pressure group&comma;” trying to push the Pope toward a particular course of action&comma; rather than offering reasoned counsel&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Spengler said internal Church problems&comma; including clergy sexual abuse and liturgical questions — which had been marked for discussion at both consistories but in the end were omitted — and other internal issues are &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;situations that concern us” and can be scandalous&period; He preferred&comma; however&comma; to highlight the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;fantastic witness” of the faithful who serve the poor and vulnerable&comma; saying&colon; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;These men and women are true saints&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Cardinal Burke more broadly questioned whether &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;synodality” is the right concept for addressing the Church’s problems&comma; whether in consistories or in the wider life of the Church&period; Both he and Cardinal Müller noted that there is still no solid&comma; agreed definition of the term&period; A cardinal during the consistory remarked that synodality tends to focus on the contemporary situation — the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;synchronic” dimension — while neglecting the &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;diachronic” dimension&comma; that is&comma; its historical context and its relationship to modernism and liberalism&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>&OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;I’m confident Our Lord will protect the Church&comma;” Cardinal Burke told the Register&comma; &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;but we have to do our part and say&colon; &OpenCurlyQuote;No&comma; this concept of synodality&comma; while it may have a good motive in the sense of wanting to address the faith to the contemporary time&comma; is fundamentally flawed&period;’” <&sol;p>&NewLine;<h3><b>Two Interventions<&sol;b> <&sol;h3>&NewLine;<p>In his intervention shared with the Register&comma; Cardinal Burke drew attention to the recent <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ewtn&period;co&period;uk&sol;article-critics-say-synod-report-undermines-church-teaching-misrepresents-courage&sol;">Synod Study Group 9’s report<&sol;a> for its attempt to normalize same-sex relations in the Church and what he and others have said is a calumny of <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;commentaries&sol;courage-apostolate-i-know-well">Courage International<&sol;a> and its apostolate to men and women who experience same-sex attractions&period; Saying the report departed from the Church’s perennial moral teaching&comma; and for unfairly discrediting Courage&comma; Cardinal Burke warned his brother cardinals that such an approach was fostering confusion&comma; division&comma; and what he saw as a politically driven agenda incompatible with the Church’s doctrinal and hierarchical structure&period; He called for a restoration of the synod’s proper theological foundations&comma; grounded in objective moral truth&comma; episcopal authority&comma; and the Church’s constant teaching&comma; as reaffirmed in <i>Veritatis Splendor<&sol;i>&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>In his <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;dianemontagna&period;substack&period;com&sol;p&sol;cardinal-mullers-intervention-at">intervention<&sol;a>&comma; Cardinal Müller expressed the same concerns about the consistory format as he shared with the Register&comma; while also raising the SSPX and the question of schism&period; He firmly rejected claims that the Church has deviated from the faith&comma; called for clarity on the canonical status of the SSPX&comma; and proposed a commission to facilitate their return to full communion under the authority of the Pope&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;p><&sol;div>&NewLine;<p><br &sol;>&NewLine;<br &sol;><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;news&sol;cardinals-reflect-on-synodal-consistory">Source link <&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><&excl;-- END THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version