Site icon Todd K Marsha

What Catholics Should Remember About Texas’ Ten Commandments Law

Notre Dame Law Takes a Wrong Turn on the Ten Commandments

<p><&excl;-- BEGIN THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p> <br &sol;>&NewLine;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>COMMENTARY&colon; The history of early public schools should make Catholics wary of allowing public officials to dictate religious affairs&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<div data-cy&equals;"articleBody">&NewLine;<p>In 1859&comma; 10-year-old <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;features&sol;5-stories-of-catholics-resisting-anti-catholicism-in-america">Thomas Whall was beaten<&sol;a> with a stick by a public-school administrator for refusing to recite the King James Version of the Ten Commandments&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Whall’s experience was <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;features&sol;5-stories-of-catholics-resisting-anti-catholicism-in-america">hardly exceptional<&sol;a> for 19th-century Catholics&period; As I have <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;ndlawreview&period;org&sol;wp-content&sol;uploads&sol;2026&sol;06&sol;Garnett-Meiser&lowbar;100&period;1709&period;pdf">written elsewhere<&sol;a>&comma; early public schools were often used to indoctrinate Catholic children in mainstream Protestantism&period; Many parents had nowhere to turn — the same groups that insisted on the King James Bible in public schools stifled Catholic schools by denying them any share of public aid&period; From Maine to Ohio&comma; violence raged when Catholics objected to mandatory Protestant Bible readings or sought support to build their own schools instead&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>These episodes remind us of the hostility that Catholics faced as they settled in this country&period; They also warn of the harm in taking away parents’ power to shape their children’s religious lives and giving it to government officials instead&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Faint echoes continue today&period; In Texas&comma; a new law requires the Ten Commandments to be posted in a way that is &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;easily read” in every public classroom&period; The displays aren’t used to teach about religion&comma; history&comma; law or anything else&period; They hang in every class&comma; from physics to fine art&comma; with no function but to confront captive audiences of children with scriptural commands&comma; all day&comma; every day&comma; for 13 years&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Texas does not demand Bible readings backed by corporal punishment&period; But the history of early public schools should make Catholics wary all the same&period; We know what it is to be a religious minority and what it is for our children to endure coerced religious instruction&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>In a <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;commentaries&sol;apb-notre-dame-law-ten-commandments">recent <i>Register <&sol;i>piece<&sol;a>&comma; however&comma; Andrea Picciotti-Bayer argues that Catholics &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;should be the first to defend” this law&period; She criticizes Notre Dame Law School’s Lindsay and Matt Moroun Religious Liberty Clinic&comma; which I direct&comma; for failing to jump aboard&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Ms&period; Picciotti-Bayer’s criticism is framed as constitutional interpretation&comma; but her charge to Catholics sounds in civics&period; She fears that opposing Texas’ law will aid secularists who view religion as &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;a hazard in public life&period;” She encourages those who see things differently to defend the place of religion in society&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Her reminder of religion’s civic value is well taken&period; But her view of Texas’ law is misguided&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The suppression of religion in public life is indeed a serious threat to religious freedom and civic flourishing&period; For decades&comma; both suffered under a know-it-when-you-see-it approach to the Establishment Clause that imposed a wooden secularism&period; The Supreme Court has begun repairing those harms&comma; rebuffing efforts to deny funding to religious institutions or scrub religion from public spaces&period; Those are important victories to defend &lpar;and ones our Clinic <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;religiousliberty&period;nd&period;edu&sol;clinic&sol;cases&sol;kennedy-v-bremerton-school-district-u-s&sol;">supported<&sol;a> at <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;religiousliberty&period;nd&period;edu&sol;clinic&sol;cases&sol;carson-v-makin-u-s&sol;">every<&sol;a> <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;religiousliberty&period;nd&period;edu&sol;clinic&sol;cases&sol;shurtleff-v-boston-u-s&sol;">step<&sol;a><u>&rpar;<&sol;u>&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>But those challenges cannot blind us to a danger on the other side&colon; allowing public officials to dictate religious affairs&period; Religious freedom is no better served when the government enforces its preferred beliefs than when it silences others’&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>A <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;religiousliberty&period;nd&period;edu&sol;news&sol;latest&sol;notre-dame-law-schools-religious-liberty-clinic-files-amicus-brief-urging-supreme-court-to-reject-state-sponsored-religious-instruction&sol;">brief our Clinic filed<&sol;a> on behalf of leading First Amendment scholars argues that Texas’ law crosses this line&period; A defining feature of religious establishments was the use of civil power to forge uniformity in religious thought&comma; and compulsory religious instruction was key to that effort&period; Defenders of religious liberty denied government that authority by adopting the First Amendment&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Texas claims the same power in modern form&period; It does not compel children to hear sermons or look upon the Decalogue in churches&period; But it requires them to attend school on pain of criminal penalties&comma; and public schools are all that many families can afford&period; By posting the Commandments throughout those schools&comma; with no function beyond showing what God requires&comma; Texas uses that coercive power to teach religious truth&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The problem isn’t that Texas brings religious texts into classrooms&period; Texas can teach an awful lot of things about religion&comma; including the civic importance of the Commandments&period; But it hasn’t&period; It has pushed a view of religious truth on a captive audience it requires to be there&period; The difference matters&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Ms&period; Picciotti-Bayer largely avoids the constitutionality of compulsory religious instruction by suggesting Texas’ version isn’t bad enough to strike down — it is a &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;silent tablet” that many find inoffensive and students might ignore&period; The implication is that it is better to allow a step in that direction than risk a ruling that invites courts to question other religious expression&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>That is a dangerous compromise that supporters of religious freedom should reject&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>The compromise is hard to contain&period; If Texas can<i> lightly<&sol;i> teach religious truth&comma; where is the limit&quest; What if the Commandments covered every wall&quest; Can teachers recite Scripture&comma; so long as students can tune them out&quest; A &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;posters only” exception is not a constitutional principle&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>More deeply&comma; mainstream comfort with an action is not constitutional justification&period; It is the reason constitutional rights exist&period; The point of the First Amendment is to protect those not in power from the excesses of those who are&period;<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>This should be old news to Catholics&period; The Protestant readings forced on Catholic children were defended as comfortable to the mainstream&period; That meant little to those who believed differently&comma; and they fought for decades before constitutional law caught up&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>We are all better off when families can access an education that fits their children’s needs&comma; including religious ones&period; Thanks to robust protections for religious equality and the ascendance of school-choice programs&comma; many can today&period; Texas opened its own program this year&period; That is a far better way to promote religious flourishing than dictating beliefs from the top&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Still&comma; not all families have that choice&comma; and the Constitution must protect them too&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Last year&comma; the Supreme Court <a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;supremecourt&period;gov&sol;opinions&sol;24pdf&sol;24-297&lowbar;4f14&period;pdf">held<&sol;a> that families of all faiths have the right to shield their children from materials in public school that interfere with their beliefs&period; It reiterated that parents — not school boards — hold the right to &OpenCurlyDoubleQuote;direct the religious upbringing of their children&period;”<&sol;p>&NewLine;<p>Families like the Whalls would hardly believe these hard-won victories against state-mandated orthodoxy&period; We must keep defending that ground&comma; even when we are personally comfortable with the beliefs on offer&period; <&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><i>John Meiser is an associate clinical professor of law and director of Notre Dame Law School’s Lindsay and Matt Moroun Religious Liberty Clinic&period;<&sol;i><&sol;p>&NewLine;<&sol;div>&NewLine;<p><br &sol;>&NewLine;<br &sol;><a href&equals;"https&colon;&sol;&sol;www&period;ncregister&period;com&sol;commentaries&sol;meiser-texas-ten-commandments-law">Source link <&sol;a><&sol;p>&NewLine;<p><&excl;-- END THEIA POST SLIDER --><&sol;p>&NewLine;

Exit mobile version