European Bishops Reiterate That Baptismal Records Should Be Protected From Erasure

9


A commission of European Union bishops has once again expressed its concern that the EU might compel ecclesiastical archives to remove the names of baptized individuals upon their request.

The Commission of the Episcopal Conferences of the European Union (COMECE) has once again expressed concern that the European Union might compel the Church to remove the names of individuals who, having left Catholicism, request the deletion of their personal data.

COMECE’s response follows an opinion by Laila Medina, advocate general at the Court of Justice of the EU, who expressed support for the position taken by a Belgian citizen who had demanded that the Diocese of Ghent delete his baptismal records.

On Nov. 20 the European bishops issued a position paper regarding the case, prepared with the support of their legal affairs commission.

In the text, COMECE clarified that a baptismal record does not necessarily reveal a person’s current beliefs, convictions, or religious affiliation; rather, it documents a sacramental event, the administration of baptism.

Furthermore, they argued that the “individual dimension of religious freedom must be placed on an equal footing with the collective and institutional dimensions of this fundamental right.”

In weighing the interests at stake, they insisted that “the ruling gives disproportionate weight to the lack of consent from the baptized person.”

They further explained that the retention of this data is necessary for the life of the Church and that proposals to delete such data are not sufficiently sound. 

Moreover, they argued that baptism is the prerequisite for receiving the other sacraments; therefore, any alteration to the register would affect the functioning of the entire sacramental life.

In the document, the bishops urged European courts to avoid interpreting canonical norms in isolation, or attributing to them meanings that run counter to the interpretation authorized by the Catholic Church.

The bishops stated that they trust that the Court of Justice of the EU will establish criteria to ensure that these records are protected from deletion, and that the balance between church and state will be maintained.



Source link

You might also like
Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.